In a major setback for homebuyers, the Maharashtra Real Estate Appellate Tribunal (MREAT) has dismissed two appeals due to an astonishing 625-day delay in filing. The case, involving stalled real estate disputes, saw the appellants blaming miscommunication with their lawyers for the lapse—an excuse the tribunal refused to accept. The order was pronounced on March 11, 2025.

Background of the Case

The appellants, Ronnie P. Mendonca and Sachin Vargantwar, had challenged a MahaRERA order from August 2022 against Samudra Darshan GruhPravesh LLP and its associates. Instead of filing their appeal within the October 2022 deadline, they sought refuge in a parallel litigation that was ultimately rejected in November 2023.

Tribunal’s Tough Stand on Delays

The tribunal, led by Chairperson S. S. Shinde and Member Shrikant M. Deshpande, ruled that the excessive delay was a result of negligence, not unforeseen circumstances. Citing Supreme Court precedents, the tribunal emphasized that legal timelines exist for a reason, and vague claims of “miscommunication” were insufficient to justify reopening the case.

In a landmark decision, the Maharashtra Real Estate Appellate Tribunal (MREAT) dismissed two appeals due to a shocking 625-day delay in filing. The tribunal ruled that mere miscommunication with legal counsel does not justify missing statutory deadlines. This verdict serves as a warning to homebuyers and litigants—time is of the essence in real estate disputes.

Final Blow to the Homebuyers

Rejecting Miscellaneous Application Nos. 523/2024 and 531/2024, the tribunal declared that the appellants had lost their chance due to their own inaction. The dismissal of Appeal Nos. AT006000000305250/2024 and AT006000000315264/2024 serves as a stark reminder—when it comes to real estate disputes, time is of the essence.

Limitation Period for Filing an Appeal Under MahaRERA:

In cases related to real estate appeals under MahaRERA, the period of limitation is governed by the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 (RERA Act) and the Limitation Act, 1963.

  • Section 44(2) of the RERA Act, 2016 states that an appeal to the Real Estate Appellate Tribunal (REAT) must be filed within 60 days from the date of the order by MahaRERA.
  • However, the tribunal may extend the limitation period if a valid reason is provided, but only if the delay is justified with “sufficient cause.”

Key Takeaways from the Case in Question:

  • The appellants delayed their appeal by 625 days, far exceeding the 60-day limit.
  • The tribunal ruled that “miscommunication with lawyers” is not a valid reason to condone such a long delay.
  • The decision aligns with Supreme Court judgments, which emphasize that delays must be explained from the start of the limitation period rather than post-expiry.

SFI Analysis: A Costly Legal Misstep

The MahaRERA Tribunal’s ruling highlights the critical importance of adhering to legal deadlines in real estate disputes. A 625-day delay, even if unintentional, was deemed unacceptable, reinforcing the judiciary’s strict stance on timely appeals. The case underscores that homebuyers and litigants must remain proactive in legal matters, ensuring clear communication with their legal counsel. Relying on parallel litigations or miscommunication as an excuse for delay can prove costly. This verdict sets a precedent, warning real estate stakeholders that procedural lapses, no matter how unintentional, can shut the door on potential legal relief.

Also Read: MahaRERA Dismisses Complaint Against Developer Over Redevelopment Dispute

You May Also Like

Indian office real estate performs better in Asia Pacific.

Indian cities have done better when it comes to office real estate…

BMC to take over empty residential buildings for quarantine

BMC came out with an order for requisitioning rooms in private buildings,…

Since Jan, 32 Realty Projects saw Change in Promoter

SInce the start of this year 32 real estate projects in the…

Worli Sees Yet Another Big Ticket Deal.

Worli has become the hotspot for big ticket deals. Several top businessmen,…