In a significant ruling that reinforces the rights of homebuyers, the Maharashtra Real Estate Appellate Tribunal has overturned an order by the Maharashtra Real Estate Regulatory Authority (RERA), clarifying that arbitration clauses in prior agreements do not override the jurisdiction of the RERA Act.  

The case involved a dispute between Mrs. Sheryll Sethi and Mr. Gurdevsingh Sethi (Appellants), who had purchased a flat in the “Kalpataru Radiance-C” project developed by Kiyana Ventures LLP (Respondent). The Appellants filed a complaint with the RERA Authority seeking possession of the flat and interest for the delayed possession.  

The RERA Authority had previously directed the parties to resort to arbitration, citing the arbitration clause in the agreement for sale. However, the Appellate Tribunal, in its recent order, emphasized that the RERA Act’s jurisdiction to protect homebuyers is not ousted by pre-existing arbitration clauses.  

Citing a judgment by the Bombay High Court, the Tribunal highlighted the non-arbitral nature of disputes between individual allottees and promoters under the RERA Act.  

The Appellate Tribunal also pointed out procedural shortcomings in the initial RERA order, noting that the Authority had decided on the maintainability of the complaint based on a preliminary issue without delving into the merits of the case, specifically the delay in handing over possession.  

To ensure a fair hearing and adherence to natural justice principles, the Appellate Tribunal quashed the RERA Authority’s order and remanded the case back to the Authority for fresh consideration on its merits. The Tribunal directed that the complaint be heard and disposed of expeditiously, considering it was initially filed in January 2024.  

This ruling is expected to have a significant impact on real estate dispute resolutions, reinforcing the RERA Act as a primary recourse for homebuyers, even in cases where prior agreements contain arbitration clauses.

Also Read: Builder cancels booking, MahaRERA orders refund

You May Also Like

Housing Prices Surge in 2024, Delhi NCR Leads with 31% Growth

India’s housing market experienced a significant price surge in 2024, with average prices rising 10% YoY. Delhi NCR led the growth with a 31% increase, followed by Bengaluru at 23%. The luxury and ultra-luxury segments played a key role in driving demand, while unsold inventory levels declined for the fourth consecutive quarter. Experts anticipate continued price appreciation in 2025, supported by strong buyer confidence and evolving housing preferences.

ANAROCK Signs Up Madhya Pradesh Housing Board for ACRM

India’s leading independent residential real estate services consultant ANAROCK Group has announced…

Unsold Affordable Housing Stock Declines 21% in 2 Years, Luxury By 5%

• As of Q1 2022-end, the total available stock of affordable housing (<INR…

Diwali is here & this is what Mumbai Builders are offering

Diwali is a festival that everyone awaits for, this Diwali is special…